Showing posts with label Oklahoma Ethics Commission. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Oklahoma Ethics Commission. Show all posts

Thursday, January 21, 2010

REESE RESPONDS TO SCURRILOUS, BASELESS ATTACK

Labor Commissioner Candidate
Rebukes Opponent for
Distracting from Issues


Labor Commissioner candidate Jason Reese responds to a report on Oklahoma Political News Service concerning an alleged campaign finance infraction.

One day after Reese publicly questioned the OK House Leadership - which includes his primary opponent Rep. Tad Jones - on a matter of policy concerning Oklahoma's small businesses and economic growth, an anonymous attack was levied against the Reese campaign.


Reese wondered about the motivation of the attack,
“I find the timing of this baseless attack very interesting, given our press release yesterday. Nonetheless, had they bothered to inquire with us directly, we could have easily supplied them with copies of the correspondence with the Ethics Commission Executive Director in which she expressly authorizes the contribution in question.”
Reese continued, “Frankly, we're not surprised by this attack and expected it at some point in the campaign. But we'd prefer our opponent stick to the issues at hand and that are of great interest to the voters rather than try to distract them with a political sideshow."

Reese is a Republican candidate for Labor Commissioner, a statewide elected post that is involved in the enforcement of workers’ compensation laws. He is also an Oklahoma City attorney who represents small and medium-sized businesses in Oklahoma with employment issues.

Thursday, February 19, 2009

Coffee Appoints Ethics Commissioner

President Pro Tempore Glenn Coffee announced Thursday that he is appointing Bob McKinney as a new Ethics Commissioner.

McKinney and his wife Marguerite have been married for 21 years and have three sons. He is a graduate of the University of Arkansas with a degree in Finance. McKinney has served as Senior Executive Vice President at RCB Bank in Claremore since 2002, with over 41 years of banking experience.

McKinney is a community leader in Claremore, including Rotary, Chamber of Commerce, Big Brothers Big Sisters and Claremore Regional Hospital.

“I am proud today to announce the appointment of a new Ethics Commissioner,” said Coffee. “Commissioner McKinney brings a wealth of experience to the Ethics Commission and we are glad he has agreed to offer his time and talents for the betterment of our state.”

Thursday, October 2, 2008

Reynolds say Governor Involved in Illegal Contributions

Gov. Brad Henry has apparently funneled $10,000 in illegal contributions to a partisan organization according to ethics records uncovered by state Rep. Mike Reynolds.

Campaign reports show that Henry donated $5,000 of his surplus campaign funds to the Young Democrats of Oklahoma in 2007 and again in 2008.

However, it is illegal for a candidate to give his or her campaign funds to any partisan organization other than a state party and its affiliates (county parties).

As a result, the Young Democrats of Oklahoma are not an official party affiliate under campaign finance law and cannot legally receive the governor’s surplus funds.

“These transactions are an obvious violation of state law,” said Reynolds, R-Oklahoma City. “Our state leaders must be held to high ethical standards that ensure fair and legally funded elections in Oklahoma. The governor’s actions do not pass that test.”

After the Young Democrats of Oklahoma received Henry’s contributions, Reynolds said that money may have been illegally used to fund the campaigns of Democratic candidates.

However, the Young Democrats of Oklahoma have failed to file any reports with the state Ethics Commission since early 2008, missing several legally required reporting deadlines that would have revealed how Henry’s money was expended.

“I don’t know why the Young Democrats would repeatedly fail to file reports in advance of the election if they have nothing to hide,” Reynolds said.

The Oklahoma City lawmaker suggested an official investigation should be launched, but noted Attorney General Drew Edmondson has also been involved campaign finance controversies. In 2007, officials learned Edmondson had given thousands of dollars in apparently illegal contributions he claimed were the result of a misunderstanding.

Edmondson also failed to investigate former State Auditor Jeff McMahan’s use of illegal straw donors in political campaigns – actions that resulted in a federal investigation and conviction for McMahan.

Saturday, September 20, 2008

Oklahoma Ethics Commission approves NEW reprimand in ethics case

The Oklahoma Ethics Commission has agreed to issue another public reprimand, presumably of a state official, but is not revealing the person's identity until a draft of the reprimand is revised.

The action came at a meeting Friday of the ethics panel, which three weeks ago reprimanded former state House Speaker Lance Cargill, R-Harrah, in a campaign fundraising case.

Ethics Commission officials would not discuss any details of the new reprimand, which was voted upon after a closed-door session.

Chairman Don Bingham of Tulsa said the identity of the person being reprimanded would be withheld until the panel's staff could make revisions to the document outlining the reasons for the action.

Bingham said details would probably be released on Tuesday.

Last month, Cargill drew a reprimand for his role in the funneling of more than $30,000 in contributions intended for the Oklahoma Republican Party to a committee of the Oklahoma County GOP for legislative races.

Some contributors complained that they intended their money to go to the state committee for general use on behalf of Republican causes and were surprised to learn that it was sent to the county.

In other action, the commission began discussion of proposed ethics rules to be submitted to the 2009 Oklahoma Legislature.

One proposal by Tulsa attorney Andrew Downing would allow companies and corporations to solicit political contributions from their employees twice a year.

Another proposal would establish a "no gift list" at the ethics agency. Legislation to set up such a list was introduced this year, but failed to win legislative approval.

John Wood, professor at Rose State College, said North Carolina has such a registry, which allows lobbyists to check for any legislators who do not want to receive gifts.

Wood said six states ban gifts altogether.

Friday, August 29, 2008

OKLAHOMA ETHICS COMMISSION PUBLICLY REPRIMANDS

This is why I blog: Oklahoma NEED a Sarah Palin for Governor in 2010 !


FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
AUGUST 29, 2008

ETHICS COMMISSION PUBLICLY REPRIMANDS REPRESENTATIVE LANCE CARGILL, THE REPUBLICAN STATE HOUSE COMMITTEE AND THE OKLAHOMA COUNTY REPUBLICAN COMMITTEE FOR MULTIPLE ETHICS RULE VIOLATIONS


The Ethics Commission today announced that it has publically reprimanded REPRESENTATIVE LANCE CARGILL, the REPUBLICAN STATE HOUSE COMMITTEE and the OKLAHOMA COUNTY REPUBLICAN COMMITTEE for multiple violations of the Constitutional Ethics Rules [“the Rules”], Section 257:1-1-1 et seq. of the Rules of the Ethics Commission, 74 O.S. Supp. 2008, Ch. 62, App.

The basis of the reprimand was stated as follows:

Simply put, this is a case of the redirection of campaign contributions intended for one party committee, to another, contrary to the intent of the donors. It resulted in the contributors being made to support candidates against their conscience and in violation of several provisions of the Ethics Rules, which are designed to safeguard campaigns in Oklahoma.

PUBLIC REPRIMAND, Statement Of The Case, 2 ¶, at p.1nd

The facts were that surplus campaign checks given by certain Republican Members of the Oklahoma House of Representatives, intended for the “Victory Fund” of the Oklahoma Republican Party [“State Party”] to support the State Party’s agenda and roster of candidates, were re-routed to the Oklahoma County Republican Committee [“OCRC” or “County Party”] and used for an entirely different slate of candidates and purposes, contrary to the indent of the donors. The reprimand document describes the activity in detail.

The Ethics Commission unanimously voted to issue the reprimand at its regular meeting held August 22, 2008, subject to the Chairman’s approval of the final draft of the document. The document was today approved for dissemination to the public and the respondents, per their attorneys of record.

Following a thorough investigation, the Commission found that the material facts were not in dispute, nor was the controlling authority. There was a deliberate intent to circumvent the law.

The Commission relied upon the testimony of four members of the House of Representatives who were surprised to learn that checks they had written to the State Party Victory Fund for ORP causes and candidates had, contrary to their will, ended up in the coffers of the County Party.

The Ethics Commission is currently made up of Chairman Don Bingham, appointed by then-Speaker Larry Adair as the appointee of the Speaker of the House of Representatives; Vice Chairman John Raley, appointee of Attorney General Drew Edmondson; James Loy, appointee of then-Chief Justice Joseph Watt of the Oklahoma Supreme Court; and Jo Pettigrew, appointee of Governor Brad Henry.

The Ethics Commission was empowered by a constitutional amendment passed in 1990 to promulgate and enforce civil penalty rules of ethical conduct for state officers and employees, as well as for state campaigns. It is authorized under Article 29, Section 4 of the Oklahoma Constitution to investigate, and when it deems appropriate, prosecute violation of its ethics rules.
-30-


*******************************

http://www.ok.gov/oec/documents/IV-2007-008-PR.pdf

-CERTIFIED MAIL-
August 29, 2008
Representative Lance Cargill
% Robert McCampbell, Attorney of Record
RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED

20 N. Broadway, Suite 1800
Oklahoma City, OK 73102-8273

Republican State House Committee
% Todd A. McKinnis, Attorney of Record
Kirkpatrick Bank Building
15 E. Fifteenth Street, Suite 200
Edmond, OK 73083-1569

Oklahoma County Republican Committee
% Tom Prince, Attorney of Record
204 E. Second Street
Edmond, OK 73083-2911

RE: INFORMATION NUMBER IV-2007-008 / LETTER OF PUBLIC REPRIMAND

Lance Cargill, Member of the Oklahoma House of Representatives; Republican State House Committee, an Oklahoma Political Action Committee; and the Oklahoma County Republican Committee, an Oklahoma Party Committee; Respondents

TO ALL RESPONDENTS:

The Ethics Commission of the State of Oklahoma met in regular meeting August 22, 2008.

It considered this matter in executive session, as required by law. In open meeting, referring to it by number, the members unanimously voted to issue all referenced Respondents a public reprimand for five (5) separate counts of violations of the Rules of the Constitutional Ethics Commission [“the Rules”], Section 1-1-1 et seq. of the Rules of the Ethics Commission, 74 O.S. Supp. 2008, Ch. 62, App.

STATEMENT OF THE CASE

Simply put, this is a case of the redirection of campaign contributions intended for one party committee, to another, contrary to the intent of the donors. It resulted in the contributors being made to support candidates against their conscience and in violation of several provisions of the Ethics Rules, which are designed to safeguard campaigns in Oklahoma.

STATEMENT OF FACTS
PERMISSIBLE WAYS IN WHICH
CAMPAIGN DOLLARS MAY BE SPENT


Use of campaign funds is strictly regulated in this State. Such money may never be converted to personal use but, together with earned interest, must defray campaign expenditures.

The law also permits those elected to access these funds for “ordinary and necessary nonreimbursed officeholder expenses,” including payment of debts of his or her former election campaign, expenses in a future race, as well as political and community activity.

Use of campaign contributions and use of surplus funds

(a) Candidate committees.

(1) Use of campaign contributions. Contributions accepted by a candidate committee may not be converted by any person to any personal use, but shall be used, together with any interest income earned on such contributions, to defray any campaign expenditures or any ordinary and necessary nonreimbursed expenses incurred by the person in connection with his duties as a holder of the state office, including, but not limited to:

(A) payment of debts of a former election campaign of the same candidate,

(B) payment of expenses for use in a future election campaign of the same candidate,

(C) for political activity,

(D) for community activity or

(E) for nonreimbursed office related expenses.

Said contributions shall not be used for any other purposes except as permitted in Paragraph (3) of this subsection.

* * *
Sec
tion 257:10-1-20(a)(1)
The Rules also specify use of surplus campaign funds – meaning the unexpended balance, not otherwise obligated for campaign debts. Those may be spent for:
* * *

(3) Use of surplus funds. The surplus funds may:

(A) be deposited with the State Treasurer to the credit of the
General Revenue Fund;

(B) be returned to the contributors pursuant to any formula approved by the candidate; provided, any amount returned to a contributor shall not exceed the amount of the original contribution;

(C) be contributed to a charitable organization;

(D) be retained by the candidate or candidate committee for use in a future election for a six-year period following the General Election for the same or a different office;

(E) be used to defend legal actions or proceedings arising out of the campaign, election, or the performance of the candidate's official
duties as a state officer; provided that such funds shall not be used to
defend criminal charges;

(F) be used for a community activity;

(G) be used for political activity;

(H) be transferred to the state or local central committee of a political party; or

(I) be distributed using a combination of these options.

* * *
Id., (3) [emphasis added]
The Rules thus permit a candidate’s surplus campaign funds to be transferred to the state or local central committee of a political party.

REPUBLICAN HOUSE MEMBERS TRANSFER SURPLUS CAMPAIGN FUNDSTO THE STATE PARTY “VICTORY FUND”


During the months of September and October in the 2004 election cycle, then-Minority Leader Todd Hiett [Hiett”] solicited campaign funds from sitting members of the Republican Caucus of the Oklahoma House of Representatives [“Republican House members”]. He asked that contributions of surplus campaign funds be made to the State Party’s “Victory Fund.”

The latter was a designated portion of ORP’s state bank account. It was used for “get-out-the vote” efforts, voter registration drives, party advertising and to help elect Republicans to state and federal office. The fund was held and operated exclusively by the Oklahoma Republican Party [“ORP” or “Republican State Party” or “State Party”]. Hiett’s solicitation was thus in accordance with Rules’ Section 257:10-1-20(a)(3)(H).

Those solicited understood that their Victory Fund contributions would be spent according to decisions made by appropriate committees and officers of the Republican State Party. The Chairman of the latter was, and is, Gary Jones [“Jones”]. Jones explained that, according to internal rules, State Party support is never the decision of a handful of people, but of many, drawn from various levels of the party. Jones said the goal is to have broad representation on the committee which decides.

THE STATE REPUBLICAN PARTY PURSUES
A BROAD-BASED AGENDA


The Victory Fund was to promote a statewide Republican effort in the 2004 elections. As noted, it encompassed a statewide voter registration drive and “get-out-the-vote” campaign. It included party advertising.

RSHC members were told that a “rising tide lifts all boats.” In other words, these measures would benefit every Republican on the ballot.

The State Party also supported certain ORP-selected state and federal candidates. Its roster included those seeking statewide office, as well as federal candidates. For instance, former- Congressman Tom Coburn received State Party support in his bid for a United States Senate seat.

COUNTY PARTIES ADVANCE
A MORE MODEST AGENDA


County parties direct their efforts in different ways. Their means are more modest, as are their goals. Even the larger ones – like those in Oklahoma and Tulsa Counties – raise far less money than does the State counterpart. County Party committees support fewer candidates.

Historically, they focus on local races. While not confined to such, they often concentrate on county elections or candidates to the State Legislature who represent areas within their borders.

Oklahoma County Republican Committee [“OCRC” or “Oklahoma County Party” or “County Party”] is a large County Party. It is an active one. Nonetheless, that entity did not fund statewide “get-out-the-vote” campaigns. It did not support candidates for federal office.

Its agenda did not mirror that of the State Republican Party. Its interests were narrower. Until 2004, OCRC may have occasionally contributed outside of Oklahoma County, but its focus was upon candidates representing districts within its boundaries.


The State and County Republican Parties therefore did not share agendas. Given what later transpired, their interests in 2004 were actually adverse.

CARGILL’S ROLE IN THE 2004 CAMPAIGNS

Representative Lance Cargill [“Cargill”] participated in the 2004 Victory Fund solicitation of Republican House members. He did this in his individual capacity. But, in reality, According to the Rules, Cargill could not serve as the official chairman of RSHC1 without committee contributions counting against his personal campaign limits. It was thus necessary for another to serve as titular committee chairman.

The total amount of Republican House member surplus fund-contributions to the Victory2 Funds was $44,000.

Several Republican House members later issued a joint statement that they did not mind3 that their donations were re-directed to the County – as opposed to the State – Republican Party Committee. The Commission notes that, when tendering a campaign contribution, present donative intent controls. A subsequent declaration does not change the payee. he acted as the “de facto” Chairman of the Republican State House Committee [“RSHC” or “House PAC”]. Several of those solicited thought he, in fact, headed RSHC.1

The operation was successful. Pursuant to the Victory Fund solicitation, the following House members wrote checks from their surplus funds to the State Party. Checks were written on the cited dates and in these amounts:

Cargill for the House Committee (9/14/04), $1,500; Friends of Don Armes
Committee (9/04/04), $1,000 and (10/06/04), $3,000; Friends of Chris Benge Committee (9/13/04), $3,500; Mark Liotta for State Rep. Committee (9/14/04), $5,000; Todd Hiett for State Rep. Committee (10/15/04), $5,000; Newport State Rep. Committee (10/18/04), $1,000; Friends of John Smaligo Committee (10/15/04), $3,000; Friends of John Smaligo Committee (10/22/04), $2,000; Friends of Raymond Vaughn Committee, $5,000; Friends of Susan Winchester Committee, $3,000; John Trebilcock for State House Committee (10/11/04), $3,500; Friends of Ron Peters Committee (10/11/04), $4,000; Committee to Re-Elect Fred Perry (10/6/04), $1,000; Friends for Dale Dewitt 2004 Committee (10/8/04), $2,500. 2

At the point of tendering these instruments, House members intended them for the State Party, since it alone had the “Victory Fund.” 3 But, the checks were diverted. Instead of the State Party – as was intended by the donors – they ended up in the coffers of the OCRC.

The reason was clear. Cargill told members that 2004 was the year the Republicans could win a majority of seats in the Oklahoma House of Representatives. Like all elections, success requires money. Cargill felt that Victory Fund money raised from House members should be spent on House races. Operatives appeared at State Party headquarters with some House members’

All checks were made payable to the “Oklahoma Republican Party,” except the4 following: Two checks from Smaligo were designated: “Republican Party.” Representative Fred Perry left blank the name of the payee. Representative Jim Newport was asked for a second check to replace the first. The latter – and it alone – was made out to “Oklahoma County Republican Party.” Representative Mark Liotta’s check bore a memo which stated: “Victory Fund Campaign Contribution” – consistent with his making the check to the “Oklahoma State Republican Party.”

After-the-fact, the word “State” was crossed out and “County” was written in, instead. campaign checks, together with a list of where those funds should be spent. Jones reluctantly permitted it on an emergency basis, but then stopped the practice. His position was that Victory Fund money was to be spent on Victory Fund – meaning statewide – efforts, and not confined to carefully selected House races.

This posed a problem. As noted, the Rules permit transferring surplus campaign funds to a State or Central Committee of a political party – not a PAC, like RSHC. Since the ORP had declined to earmark House-raised funds for expenditures in certain House races, another party committee was needed. Al Mertens, then serving as OCRC Chairman, agreed to accommodate the Cargill/RSHC plan. The OCRC board later acquiesced.

ORP VICTORY FUND CHECKS
ARE ROUTED TO THE COUNTY PARTY


The County Party received the above- listed donations intended for the ORP Victory Fund.

It began paying for polling, compensation of campaign workers called “Field Reps,” and other expenses associated with select House races.

While the record supports a broader finding, the Commission has chosen to base its case upon the testimony of four Republican House members who have maintained throughout they never intended donations of their surplus campaign funds to go anywhere but the State Republican Party.

Those four are: Hiett, Representative Susan Winchester [“Winchester”], former Representative Ray Vaughn [“Vaughn”] and Representative John Trebilcock [“Trebilcock”].

The surplus campaign checks – including the checks of these four – were either collected from Republican House members by Cargill and/or his designees, agents or employees. Or, they were mailed to the State Party, but somehow ended up with titular Chairman of RSHC, Aaron Curry [“Curry”]. These surplus campaign checks were made payable to “ORP, the “Oklahoma Republican Party” or a variation of that name – with the intent that the funds go to the State Party.4 A number of Rule violations ensued.

RULE VIOLATIONS

COUNT ONE
The Rules require those gathering or receiving contributions to provide them to the payee’s treasurer within five (5) days of receipt. The State Republican Party Treasurer never received them.

In gathering Republican House members’ checks to the Victory Fund, Cargill and RSHC were jointly and severally charged with providing these instruments to the State Party treasurer within five days. This was never done, in violation of Rules’ Section 257:10-1-10(d), which provides:
Campaign depositories and campaign accounts
* * *
(d) All contributions, other than in-kind contributions, accepted by the committee,
directly or indirectly, shall be deposited in a campaign account within ten (10) days after
acceptance. All contributions received by a deputy treasurer or agent of the committee,
including the candidate, on behalf of a committee shall be provided to the treasurer or,
in the treasurer's absence, the deputy treasurer not later than five (5) days after receipt.
* * *
Section 257:10-1-10

COUNT TWO
Certain of these House member checks were tendered without a Contributor Statement.

Contributions of John Trebilcock and Ray Vaughn were not accompanied by the Statement. Nor has any been provided to date, because neither ever filled out nor signed the form.

Both checks were cashed in the absence of a Contributor Statement. Their contributions were therefore accepted, and deposited, in violation of Rules’ Section 257:10-1-2(c). Contributions
* * *
(c) Contributor statement. Within ten (10) business days of accepting a single
contribution exceeding fifty dollars ($50.00), or before accepting multiple contributions from a single source which exceed fifty dollars ($50.00) in the aggregate, persons accepting contributions must obtain from each contributor a statement which shall include:

(1) the date the contribution was given;

(2) the name and address, occupation [e.g."retail sales clerk"] and
employer [e.g. "Dillard"], or principal business activity of the contributor; a contribution from a person other than an individual or a committee shall be reported by the name of the person or committee and not the individual who signed the check;

(3) the amount; if in-kind, a description of the contribution and a good faith estimate of its fair market value;

(4) a declaration that the contribution is for a campaign in the State of Oklahoma, and the contribution is freely and voluntarily given from the contributor's personal property, if an individual, or the person or committee's property, if other than an individual;

(5) a declaration that the contributor has not been directly or indirectly compensated or reimbursed for the contribution, if an individual, and, if a person other than an individual or a committee, that the person or committee has not been compensated or reimbursed for the contribution by persons:

(A) other than those from whom contributor statements have been received and of whom disclosure has or will be made; or

(B) if from persons exempted from the definition of political action committee, by other persons; and

(6) the signature of the contributor, or in the case of a committee, the treasurer or, in the treasurer's absence, the deputy treasurer of the committee.

Persons accepting contributions from contributors who contribute by payroll deduction, dues check-off, or similar process shall be required to obtain only one contributor statement annually or at such other times as a change is made in the deduction, check- off, or similar process.
Section 257:10-1-2(c)

COUNT THREE
Curry offered OCRC the campaign checks with the stipulation that the funds be used to pay specified expenses incurred by RSHC. Expenses included background research into opposing candidates by the law firm of Hartzog, Conger et al., polling by Cole Hargrave Snodgrass & Associates for a 300-sample survey, "brushfire polls" conducted by Lowther & Shapard in certain races, and various salaries or fees of Field Reps or consultants. Earmarking contributions to pay expenditures for the benefit of certain candidates violated the provisions of Rules’ Section 257:10-1-
2(j)(2) as follows:

Contributions
(j) Anonymous and earmarked contributions.

* * *
(2) For purposes of the contribution limitations imposed by this section, all contributions made by a person, either directly or indirectly, to or for the benefit of a particular candidate committee, including contributions which are in any way earmarked or otherwise directed through an intermediary or conduit to such candidate committee, shall be treated as contributions from such person to such candidate committee. It shall be prohibited for an intermediary or a conduit to make a contribution to a committee in his or her own name rather than the name of the original source of such contribution. For purposes of this paragraph, an intermediary or conduit means a person, who is not the treasurer, deputy treasurer or agent of a committee, but who is given a contribution by another with the understanding that it will be contributed to that committee. The reports shall show the correct name of the person actually
making the contribution.
* * *
Section 257:10-1-2(j)(2)
As noted, after accommodating no more than two requests on an emergency basis, Jones declined to permit RSHC to earmark Victory Funds for specific races. It was this decision that caused the House PAC to turn to OCRC to do its bidding.

COUNT FOUR
Cargill, RSHC and OCRC then devised a scheme whereby RSHC would circumvent the State Party and direct how the surplus funds were spent. They were aware that surplus candidate campaign funds may not be used as contributions to political action committees [“PACs”]. That precluded depositing the funds in RSHC. They were also aware that, under Section 257:10-1- 20(3)(H), the Rules permit surplus campaign funds to be transferred to the state or local central committee of a political party.
Use of campaign contributions and use of surplus funds

(a) Candidate committees.
* * *
(3) Use of surplus funds. The surplus funds may:
* * *
(H) be transferred to the state or local central committee of a political
party; or
* * *
Section 257:10-1-20(a)(3)(H)
In violation of this rule, Respondents planned to deposit these checks into a county party and have it pay expenses they or RSHC incurred to support their hand-picked candidate campaigns. The plan included earmarking contributions by limiting how the funds might be spent. The County Party was to function as an intermediary or conduit.

Cargill at first considered the Creek County Republican Party as the intermediary/conduit. OCRC was chosen, instead. The matter was discussed with OCRC then-Chairman Al Mertens [“Mertens”] who agreed. Curry – or his agent, employee or designee – delivered all or part of the above listed checks to OCRC, along with the specific bills and invoices the County Party was to pay.

Rules’ Section 257:10-1-10(d) requires that contributions accepted by an agent of a committee be turned over to the treasurer, or deputy treasurer, within five days of receipt. If directly or indirectly accepted by a committee, the rule then requires the money be deposited in the committee’s campaign account within ten (10) days after such acceptance. As noted, Curry, who accepted the checks from Cargill, failed to timely deliver the checks to the State Party’s treasurer – or deputy treasurer – within five days of receipt in violation of Section 257:10-1-10(d). Instead, he presented them to Mertens, who caused them to be deposited, illegally, in OCRC’s account.

OCRC thus violated this provision.


Outside the lawful time line for acceptance, the County Party not only deposited these checks, it began paying for political consultants, polls and Field Rep’s – expenses incurred by Cargill/RSHC in furtherance of their plan to use State Party money, not for the ORP roster, but earmarking the funds to help elect their personal choice of candidates.

A key part of the scheme was that OCRC was to act as the conduit for RSHC. As noted, the County Party was to accept money from Victory Fund contributors and pay bills to support designated candidates.

Under Section 257:10-1-2(j), contributions which are in any way directed through an intermediary, or conduit, to a candidate committee in its name – rather than the name of the original source – are treated as contributions from the true donor. This means that RSHC checks given to candidates – together with its expenses incurred to assist these candidates (paid for by OCRC) – counted against RSHC’s contribution limits.

COUNT FIVE
Curry served both as RSHC Chair and Treasurer from January 5, 2003 to January 28, 2005.

Jenny Parton [“Parton”] then took over both positions. Parton continued in her dual role until October 17, 2006, when she was replaced by Carolyn Pickthorn [“Pickthorn”], who likewise served as Chair and Treasurer. According to Ethics Commission records, Pickthorn continues in these capacities to date. All have certified the RSHC Campaign Contributions and Expenditures Reports [“Form C-1R”]. These C-1Rs are inaccurate, in that they fail to include the funds involved in the conduit scheme. All are thus in violation of Rules’ Section 257:10-1-14(a)(3) and (20) which
provide.

Report contents
(a) Basic reporting form. The campaign contributions and expenditures report shall include:
* * *
(3) the following information about monetary contributions, including
loans accepted from a person other than a committee:

(A) the total sum of all contributions accepted during
the current reporting period . . .

(B) the total of contributions accepted for the
campaign-to-date or calendar year-to-date . . .
* * *
(20) the signature, or typed signature on electronically filed forms of the treasurer or, in the treasurer's absence, the deputy treasurer, who shall certify that prior to accepting any contribution requiring a contributor statement during this campaign-to-date for candidate committees or calendar year-to-date for other committees, the treasurer, or deputy treasurer in the treasurer’s absence, received a contributor statement therefor and who shall each attest to the report's accuracy and veracity. Within five (5) business days of the treasurer or deputy treasurer of a candidate committee filing a required report, the candidate, or the treasurer of a candidate committee for a candidate seeking judicial office, shall confirm in writing that the report filed was true and correct. The signature shall be verified. Section 257:10-1-14(a)(3) and (20)

In agreeing to this plan, Mertens and other OCRC officers joined Cargill/RSHC in contravening Rules’ Sections 257:10-1-10(d) and 10-1-2(j)(2). All checks, exceeding fifty dollars ($50.00), were accepted unlawfully by the treasurer of a different committee and in the absence of a Contributor Statement. As such, these checks were illegally accepted, deposited and spent by the County Party and were used to pay expenses incurred by RSHC.

From January 28, 2002 to July 6, 2006, Elizabeth A, Rolen [“Rolen”] served as OCRC Treasurer. In such capacity, she prepared and filed a series of C-1Rs on behalf of OCRC. She dated the form and, as treasurer of OCRC, signed her name to the following:

To the best of my knowledge and belief, the above is a true and correct compilation.

Prior to accepting a contribution requiring a contributor statement during this campaign or calendar year-to-date, the treasurer or deputy treasurer received a contributor statement therefor. . . FORM C-1R, Certification, at line 26 [emphasis added] OCRC violated Rules’ Section 257:10-1-14(a)(20) by filing a report in the absence of Contributor Statements. Each instance forms a separate count. OCRC also violated that provision when Rolen, as its treasurer, certified as correct totals – and campaign-to-date totals – which illegally included contributions that OCRC was not authorized to accept and did so without the mandatory Contributor Statements. Each instance of filing such a report also forms a separate count of a Rule 10-1-14(a)(20) violation.

Robert L. Bowman [“Bowman”] took over from Rolen on July 6, 2006. Ethics Commission records show he served as OCRC Treasurer from that time to October 1, 2007. As treasurer, he also prepared and filed C1-R reports which violated these same provisions. OCRC likewise violated Rules’ Section 257:10-1-14(a)(20) by certifying as correct totals, and campaign-to-date totals, which illegally included contributions without the Contributor Statement. Each instance of filing such a report constitutes a separate count of a Rule 10-1-14(a)(20) violation.

A C-1R report filed January 25, 2007 by Representative Mike Duane Jackson [“Jackson”], the Republican nominee in House District #40, listed an expenditure of $3,500 marked as contribution for voter recount. But, on May 17, 2007, Jackson filed an amended C1-R. It showed that a monetary transfer of $3,500 had been made on November 9, 2006 to OCRC. Jackson then deleted the expenditure of the same date for the voter recount. In this matter, Cargill/RSHC again utilized OCRC as a conduit/intermediary. The one solicited surplus funds for the other, so that the County Party might contribute the exact amount for use in the voter recount. In so doing, they again violated Rules’ Sections 257:10-1-2(a)(2) and 10-1-20(a)(H).

In addition, OCRC used House members’ surplus campaign funds to pay the following expenses: Cole Snodgrass Hargrave & Associates — House District [“HD”]13, Stuart Ericson, $2,700; HD45, Thad Balkman, $2,450; HD23, Sue Tibbs, $2,450; HD09, Tad Jones, $2,200; HD26, Kris Steele, $2,800; HD61, Gus Blackwell, $2,450 — less $5,000 "paid by PAC;" Party check #2,500 paid $10,550 toward these expenses. A facsimile transmittal from Veda Shapard, Lowther & Shapard, advised that Aaron Curry had instructed the forwarding of invoices ($500 each) to the Oklahoma County Republican Committee for payment of the following: brushfire polls for the races of HD 61 (Gus Blackwell), HD 13 (Stuart Ericson), HD 8 (Bill Kendrick), HD 12 (Mark Wofford), HD 22 (Preston Edgar), and HD 26 (Kris Steele). Bills from several consultants were also paid by the Oklahoma County Republican Party for candidates races well outside Oklahoma County.

PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE COMMISSION
AUTHORITY TO INVESTIGATE
The Commission has carried out the investigation of this information pursuant to its constitutional mandate to “investigate and, when it deems appropriate, prosecute” violations of its rules governing ethical conduct of state officers, employees and state campaigns. OKLA. CONST. Art.29, §4(A); §3(A) and (B) The instant proceeding has been conducted in accordance with Rules’ Chapter 30.

SCOPE OF THE INVESTIGATION
The Commission has conducted a thorough investigation into this matter. It has interviewed witnesses, collected documents and searched records. It fully reviewed multiple aspects of this matter. The material facts are not in dispute.

The breadth of these facts, coupled with the complexity of the investigation, has caused the Commission to pursue the RSHC and OCRC committees, rather than their officers. Individuals’ names are required for purposes of the fact record.

JURISDICTION/VENUE
The Commission has and retains both in personam and subject matter jurisdiction over Respondents and all aspects of the conduct in question. The acts charged against Respondents occurred in Oklahoma County, State of Oklahoma, where venue lies.

REPRESENTATION BY COUNSEL
The Commission notes each Respondent was been apprised of the right to be represented by counsel. Each has been represented by counsel of his/their own choosing. Attorneys of record have been afforded the opportunity to reply to all allegations. All did, in fact, reply. Their responses were carefully reviewed and considered by the Commissioners.

REPRIMAND
This letter constitutes the Commission’s Public Reprimand of the Respondents for the cited rule violations. It does not speak to state statutes or provisions of the Oklahoma Constitution but, instead, is confined to the Rules which the Commission enforces.

The Commissioners are charged with enforcing ethical conduct of state officers, employees and campaigns in Oklahoma. This reprimand is the act of the full Commission and not of its staff.

It was authorized in open meeting by a unanimous vote of all four Commissioners. In accordance with agency policy, the final draft of this document was approved by the undersigned, in his capacity as Ethics Commission Chairman. A copy will be immediately provided to the Capitol Media Corps for public dissemination.

This concludes the matter.


Sunday, May 18, 2008

Cost of (Ethics Commission) computer upgrade disputed





Cost of computer upgrade disputed

By MICK HINTON World Capitol Bureau

OKLAHOMA CITY — The state ethics director on Friday disputed a senator's claim that it would cost $150,000 to adapt a computerized campaign reporting system that the agency doesn't want.

The real cost is more like $750,000 and possibly as much as $1 million, Ethics Commission Executive Director Marilyn Hughes said.

The Legislature is planning to give the Ethics Commission only $50,000 this session for the computer conversion.

Legislators and ethics commissioners are feuding over the agency's funding bill, which earmarks the money to pattern Oklahoma's campaign reporting system after the Federal Election Commission's.

Ethics commissioners are strongly opposed to adapting to the FEC system because they say it fails to meet the requirements of Oklahoma's campaign reporting laws.

Oklahoma's laws limit contributions from an individual or family to $5,000 during a campaign cycle, which can last two years or more. But the FEC system does not provide for cumulative totals throughout a campaign, so it cannot be determined whether a contributor exceeds the limit, Hughes said.

On the other hand, some lawmakers and political action committees have complained that the Ethics Commission's current reporting system is slow and hard to operate compared with the federal system.

Paul Ziriax, a spokesman for the Senate Republicans, said Friday that there have been "numerous complaints" that the current electronic reporting software is "seriously flawed" and needs to be replaced with something more "user-friendly."

Senate President Pro Tem Glenn Coffee said $150,000 would cover the cost of the system conversion. He said the $50,000 appropriated by the House would give the commission a good start.

Coffee said he wanted the entire $150,000 appropriated but that the House and Governor's Office were not in agreement.

Coffee, R-Oklahoma City, said Senate Republicans had asked the vendor how much the changeover would cost.

"I made an inquiry with the software vender, and they said there were a lot of variables, and it would be difficult to predict," he said. "But that was their best estimate."

Hughes produced an e-mail Friday from the vendor that stated a price of "over $750,000 plus additional maintenance the first year to put the total over $1 million."

Senate leaders were trying Friday to get the vendor to recheck the cost.

Neither Coffee nor Hughes has received an official estimate to convert the Oklahoma system.



Mick Hinton (405) 528-2465
mick.hinton@tulsaworld.com

Friday, May 2, 2008

Oklahoma Ethics Commission Launches New Web site

The Oklahoma Ethics Commission (OEC) recently launched a new and improved Web site. At the new OEC Web site, visitors can easily obtain information relating to campaign reporting, lobbyist reporting and Oklahoma ethics laws.

“Our new Web site gives us the opportunity to communicate more effectively with public officers and employees, lobbyists, political candidates, and the media. We strive to provide rules of ethical conduct for state officers and employees and campaigns and provide all visitors to our site with easy access to state disclosure information,” said Marilyn Hughes, OEC Executive Director.

The Web site is designed to meets Oklahoma’s web accessibility standards and was built utilizing OK.gov’s Content Management System. The system also allows the Ethics Commission’s staff to provide the most up-to-date information quickly and efficiently. OEC invites Oklahoma citizens to visit their new Web site and learn more about Oklahoma’s ethical practices.

Visit the NEW Oklahoma Ethics Commission Web site

Saturday, March 15, 2008

Clause aims at power of ethics board





Clause aims at power of ethics board

By MICK HINTON World Capitol Bureau

OKLAHOMA CITY -- The state Ethics Commission expressed alarm Friday that an effort may be under way to make the campaign watchdog group powerless.

Rep. Mike Reynolds, R-Oklahoma City, informed commissioners that he had discovered a clause slipped into a measure that would take away the commission's power to name its own director, "whose duties will be defined by the Legislature."

Voters established the Ethics Commission by approving a constitutional change in 1990 that set up the independent body whose major duty is monitoring political campaigns, including those of legislators.

"This is alarming when the heart and soul of the Ethics Commission is not only to operate in a nonpartisan manner but to have total and absolute independence," said Commissioner John Raley of Ponca City.

Reynolds told the commission that he learned it was former House Speaker Lance Cargill who requested the language, which Reynolds said later would "destroy the commission."

However, Cargill issued a statement that Reynolds' claim "is 100 percent false."

Cargill said he did not learn about the controversial provision until Friday.

"And today, Reynolds spun a web of deceit about me for the commission that was completely false and reckless," Cargill said. "There is no better proof than (Reynolds') actions today that the commissioners should be very careful about believing anything Rep. Reynolds said."

Rep. Ken Miller, whose House Joint Resolution 1099 contains the ethics change, also said Cargill did not have a role in getting the language inserted into the measure.

The House approved the resolution on Thursday. Cargill, R-Harrah, noted that Reynolds voted for the measure. Reynolds countered that first he managed to get the title stricken from the bill, meaning it will have to return to the House for another vote.

Cargill, who stepped aside as speaker in late January after news reports about his tax problems surfaced, had asked the House staff to put together a bill calling for changes to bolster the governor's power, which he had proposed in a "100 Ideas" book, said Miller, R-Edmond.

The Ethics Commission reportedly has been investigating activities of the House Republican political action committee in the 2004 elections, when Cargill was chairman of the PAC.

Rick Farmer, director of the House committee staff, put together the measure calling for making the directors of four agencies gubernatorial appointees. Farmer decided on his own to include the ethics director, Miller said.

Miller said Friday that in retrospect, it probably was not the best idea to take away the Ethics Commission's independence, which had been authorized by a vote of the people.

"The Ethics Commission will be taken out of the bill as soon as I can change it," Miller said.

Meanwhile, ethics commis sioners put on their April 18 agenda to discuss their budget problems. The commissioners said they will invite House and Senate leaders and the governor to attend.

Reynolds had proposed giving the commission about $300,000 more in funding after Ethics Commission officials said they have cramped quarters in the basement of the Capitol and have had to borrow paper to operate.

Miller noted Friday that their request would be a 70 percent increase at a time when there are few budget dollars.

Change alarms Ethics Commission





Change alarms Ethics Commission

The State Ethics Commission expressed alarm Friday that there is a movement afoot by some members of the Legislature to make powerless the watchdog group authorized by a vote of the people.

Rep. Mike Reynolds, R-Oklahoma City, informed commissioners that he had discovered a clause slipped into an ethics measure earlier that would take away the power of the commission to name its own director "whose duties will be defined by the Legislature."

Reynolds told the commission that he learned it was former House Speaker Lance Cargill who requested the language that the lawmaker said would "destroy the commission."

Cargill, who stepped aside as speaker in late January after news reports about his tax problems, has been the subject of an ethics commission probe due to questionable activities when he headed the House Political Action Committee.

The commission applauded Reynolds for bringing the information to their attention. Commissioner Don Bingham asked those who wanted such a measure put into law to publicly state why they wanted legislation that apparently would weaken the commission, which monitors political campaigns for irregularities.

Tuesday, March 4, 2008

House committee passes sweeping ethics measure




House committee passes sweeping
ethics measure

Mon March 3, 2008

OKLAHOMA CITY - Ethics legislation that prohibits fundraising by lawmakers during legislative sessions and forbids cash transfers between political action committees was sent to the floor of the Oklahoma House Monday.

Lawmakers gave preliminary approval to the measure after its author, Rep. Dave Dank, R-Oklahoma City, said the Legislature needs to tighten rules governing ethical conduct and campaign financing by elected officials to restore the public's faith in them.

"A lot of citizens don't trust us," Dank told members of the House Rules Committee. "They think some of us are for sale."

Committee members also passed legislation by Rep. Jason Murphey, R-Guthrie, that would create a "No Gist List" of lawmakers who do not want gifts or anything else of value given to them by lobbyists.

An amendment approved by committee members would expand the list to include all elected officials subject to state ethics rules, including statewide officials.

Dank's bill, dubbed the Oklahoma Clean Campaign Act of 2008, prohibits fundraising by legislators or legislative candidates during regular legislative sessions as well as 15 days before and after sessions.

Dank said he wants to end questions about whether passage of legislation may be tied to campaign donations.

"There must be a healthy distance between the process of raising money and making law," Dank said. "Otherwise citizens will suspect — sometimes with justification — that legislation is for sale at the state Capitol."

The measure also forbids PAC-to-PAC transfers, requires that campaign funds be used only for legitimate campaign expenditures and equalizes the status of all campaign donors, more clearly defining groups and individuals eligible to contribute.

"For decades there have been clouds over the whole business of raising and spending campaign money in Oklahoma state government," Dank said. Provisions that capped total contributions from individuals and mandating some reporting procedures were removed from the bill to make it simpler, he said.

"It's a bill about some basic principles," Dank said. "I hope no one will have a fear over this bill. It has strong support from the people who pay our salaries."

Members of the committee voted for the bill without opposition or debate. The bill's title was struck, a procedure that will eventually send the bill to a joint House-Senate conference committee.

In January, the Oklahoma Ethics Commission adopted a rule to stop PAC-to-PAC transfers, which critics say allow the identity of big campaign contributors to be hidden.

Supporters say the rule promotes open government and accountability in the campaign financing system. Like individuals, PACs are limited to giving candidates for office $5,000 per election cycle, but critics say the PAC loophole allowed large amounts of cash to be funneled to certain candidates without public disclosure.

Former House Speaker Lance Cargill, who resigned in January following a series of embarrassing revelations, has been the subject of an ethics investigation into his fundraising activities.

Cargill, R-Harrah, was criticized after being installed as speaker when he summoned lobbyists to a private consultant's office away from the Capitol to ask them for contributions to political action committees.

He also came under fire for attending a fundraiser for presidential candidate Mike Huckabee at the home of a Texas businessman linked to Carroll Fisher, the former state insurance commissioner who was impeached and is now in prison on corruption charges.

The ethics bill is House Bill 2196.

Saturday, February 23, 2008

State corruption cases come in bunches



State corruption cases come in bunches

By RON JENKINS

OKLAHOMA CITY (AP) _ It's been a rough time for some elected officials in Oklahoma in recent months, leading citizens to question what's going on and causing soul searching over the state's level of corruption.

Gov. Brad Henry is among those who discount the notion that public corruption is any more prevalent in Oklahoma than in most other states, despite a rash of officials being charged with crimes or caught in embarrassing situations.

"Oklahomans are some of the most caring, most ethical people in the country and I think Oklahoma state elected officials are, too," Henry said. "Unfortunately, we've had some unfortunate situations here in the last several months.

"But we need to let the criminal and legislative processes play out and see what happens before we make any ultimate determinations."

William S. Price is a former U.S. attorney in Oklahoma whose office won convictions against 240 county commissioners, former commissioners and material suppliers during the late 1970s and early 1980s in what the FBI classified as the most widespread corruption case in U.S. history.

Price believes public corruption in Oklahoma could be a systemic problem caused partly by a lack of checks and balances in the county commissioner system of government, with officials developing bad habits they take with them to higher office.

But he also says he does not believe corruption is a cultural problem in Oklahoma, like it is elsewhere in the country.

"We never had trouble getting convictions," he said. "I think when the people of Oklahoma learn of corruption involving their public officials they tend to demand their resignation. They tend to put them in jail."

"I don't think we are any more corrupt than anybody else by a long shot," adds John Raley, a former U.S. attorney in Muskogee and a member of the Oklahoma Ethics Commission. Raley is an outspoken proponent of restricting spending by lobbyists and increased public disclosure of activities of legislators and state officials.

Figures compiled by the Public Integrity Division of the Justice Department in a 2007 report to Congress lends credence to the comments of Henry, Price and Raley.

The report showed that over a decade ending in 2006, there were 106 federal convictions in public corruption cases involving judicial districts in Oklahoma City, Tulsa and Muskogee.

That is a fraction of convictions in jurisdictions in larger states, led by 574 in northern Florida, 412 in northern Illinois, 399 in central California, 377 in New Jersey, 362 in northern Ohio, 359 in eastern Pennsylvania and 352 in southern New York.

But in the last few months, those "unfortunate situations" Henry spoke of have dominated the news amid calls in the Legislature for ethics reform.

Among other things:

— State Auditor and Inspector Jeff McMahan and his wife have been hit with federal charges tied to allegedly accepting jewelry and other gifts, plus excessive campaign contributions, from a man implicated in another public corruption case.

— Rep. Lance Cargill was forced to resign as House speaker after he faced insurrection from fellow caucus members over ethics questions and late payment of income and property taxes. Some lawmakers said their constituents were angered by the tax disclosures.

— Labor Commissioner Lloyd Fields was compelled to issue a public apology after he was taken from a party for rodeo performers to a detox center. Witnesses said Fields tried to walk away with an expensive guitar at the party. Fields said it was a practical joke gone bad.

Former Insurance Commissioner Carroll Fisher is currently in prison on a state embezzlement charge linked to campaign financing and is awaiting trial on bribery and corruption charges.

The decade began with a scandal at the Oklahoma Department of Health, with the acting commissioner of health being convicted on federal bribery charges.

Meanwhile, the Oklahoma attorney general prosecuted several other Health Department employees and officials as ghost employees who did little or no work for their pay and benefits.

As McMahan awaits a federal trial in Muskogee, the new speaker of the House, Rep. Chris Benge of Tulsa, has appointed a committee to study the possibility of bringing impeachment articles against the state official.

Fisher was impeached by the House in 2004 and resigned before a Senate trial. It was the first impeachment since former Secretary of State John Rogers in 1975. The last trial by the Senate led to the conviction of former Supreme Court Justice N.B. Johnston in a bribery case.

Oklahoma has had its share of high-profile public corruption cases over the last few decades, the most notable leading to a federal prison term in the mid-1970s for former Gov. David Hall. A former Tulsa prosecutor, Hall was convicted in a bribery-extortion case linked to the investment of retirement funds.

David Walters, another former governor, pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor offense tied to an alleged scheme to collect excessive campaign donations when he was a candidate. The offense has been expunged from the court records under an agreement with prosecutors.

In another sensational case from the 1990s, Patricia Whitehead, deputy state treasurer and two others were convicted of federal crimes in a kickback scheme that involved $6.7 million in illegal payments from investment of state funds. Treasurer Claudette Henry was never charged in the case, but the scandal led to her defeat for re-election in 1994. She died after a long illness five years later.

Several legislators and former legislators have been charged with various crimes over the years, ranging from accepting bribes to cocaine distribution.

Most recently, former Rep. Mike Mass pleaded guilty to mail fraud for allegedly conspiring with ex-Sen. Gene Stipe and others to defraud taxpayers through improper use of economic development funds appropriated by the Legislature.

Kiowa businessman Steve Phipps is a key witness for the federal government in that case and in the case against McMahan. Phipps was a longtime business partner of Stipe and was the owner of abstract companies regulated by McMahan's office.

Stipe has been found to have dementia and declared mentally incompetent to stand trial. The government is trying to commit him to a federal prison hospital.

The determination of incompetency against Stipe came as prosecutors were attempting to revoke his probation for a previous campaign law violation.

Stipe's trial is pending in the corruption case in which his brother, Francis, also is charged.

Indictments accuse the Stipes of illegally steering state money to private businesses. They also are accused of witness tampering by purchasing a house for Mass.


While saying Oklahoma juries are among "the least tolerant of corruption," Price said his talks with other prosecutors led him to believe convictions are not so easy to come by in other areas of the country.

He said the Oklahoma public's staunch stand against corruption has not been "true in Louisiana at all, and I don't think it is true in some of the big cities of the Northeast."

On the other hand, he said a tier of northern and midwestern states without huge cities have had relatively little corruption by comparison, mentioning Oregon, Minnesota and Wisconsin and Maine.

Price said local government corruption appears to be a problem in Oklahoma and many southern states that have a county commissioner form of government, where three people exercise a lot of power on their own.

He said Kansas had a county manager form of government and has not had the same problems.

Saturday, February 16, 2008

Top 10 legislative candidates in cash on hand







Top 10 legislative candidates in
cash on hand

Through Dec. 31, 2007

Sen. Susan Paddack, D-Ada $308,241.18

Sen. Johnnie Crutchfield,D-Ardmore $234,470.33

Rep. Dennis Adkins, R-Tulsa $183,713.81

Sen. Thomas Adelson, D-Tulsa $169,087.00

Rep. Lucky Lamons, D-Tulsa $165,013.14

Rep. Ron Peters, R-Tulsa $157,319.04

Rep. Rob Johnson, R-Kingfisher $139,279.40

Rep. Lance Cargill, R-Harrah $128,827.03

*James Halligan, Stillwater $128,308.54

Rep. Danny Morgan,D-Prague $128,001.78

*Republican candidate for Senate District 21

Source: Oklahoma Ethics Commission

GOP lead in $$$





Republicans in state have more funds
By RANDY KREHBIEL World Staff Writer
2/16/2008


Republicans have more campaign cash,
but Democrats have 4 of the top 5 balances.


Heading into this election year, Republican legislators and legislative candidates had about $1 million more to spend on their campaigns than Democrats, according to reports filed with the Oklahoma Ethics Commission.

Republicans' cash on hand at the end of 2007 totaled just under $3.1 million, compared with $2.1 million for Democrats. Reports were filed for almost 200 active candidate campaigns, including all 151 current legislators.

"Money might always seem to be an advantage but it's not, really," said state Democratic Party Chairman Ivan Holmes. Holmes pointed out that Democrats Ken Luttrell and Eric Proctor managed to win previously Republican House seats in 2006 with very little money.

The Ethics Commission figures include accounts for term-limited Sen. Jim Williamson, R-Tulsa, whose legislative campaign fund has been essentially dormant since 2005, and Rep. Rob Johnson, R-Kingfisher, who has also opened a corporation commission campaign fund.

The figures do not include old campaign accounts maintained by current and former legislators, nor do they include figures from the more than 300 active political action committees registered with the Ethics Commission.

Despite the Republicans' overall cash advantage, four of the five largest balances belong to Democrats.

Of particular note is the war chest accumulated by Sen. Susan Paddack of Ada. Paddack raised $160,000 in the last three months of 2007 and had more than $308,000 in cash at year's end. Her donors include several known primarily as Republican contributors, including Oklahoma City energy tycoon Aubrey McClendon, Tom Love of Love's Travel Stops and Country Stores, Oklahoma City furniture store owner Bill Mathis and Seattle SuperSonics owner Clayton Bennett.

Second on the list is Sen. Johnnie Crutchfield, D-Ardmore, with just under $235,000. Crutchfield has said he built a large balance expecting a 2006 challenge that never came. Now term-limited, Crutchfield has said he will probably give away anything left in the account after he leaves office in 2010.

The top Republican and top House member is Rep. Dennis Adkins of Tulsa, followed by Sen. Tom Adelson, D-Tulsa; Rep. Lucky Lamons, D-Tulsa; and Rep. Ron Peters, R-Tulsa.

Johnson, who announced in January he intends to run for the Corporation Commission, still had almost $140,000 in his House campaign fund at the end of 2007.

Former Oklahoma State University President James Halligan, Republican candidate for the vacant Senate District 21 seat, is making a strong bid for rookie of the year in fundrais ing terms. Halligan, who announced his candidacy only a few months ago, had already taken in $131,000 by the end of the year and reported a balance of more than $128,000. His contributions included $15,000 from various PACs associated with Senate Republicans and another $15,000 from a Texas ranching family with OSU ties.

Republicans are counting on Halligan and the defeat of Sen. Nancy Riley in west Tulsa County's District 37 to gain control of the Senate for the first time in history. Riley, a former GOP candidate for lieutenant governor, switched parties in 2006 to stymie a Republican takeover.

To this point, only one potentially serious Democratic challenger to a sitting Republican has appeared -- Norman attorney Diane Drum, who is going after District 15 incumbent Jonathan Nichols.

Holmes, the Democratic party chairman, said he thinks Elgin businessman Rick Wolfe will make a capable candidate in southwest Oklahoma's District 31 and vows to find a viable opponent for Halligan.

Primaries are set for July 29; the general election is Nov. 4.


Randy Krehbiel 581-8365
randy.krehbiel@tulsaworld.com

Saturday, February 2, 2008

Gov. Brad and X-Speaker has extra Cash on Hand


Gov. Brad Boy, 2006 campaign raised nearly $5 million, still has $459,290 on hand.

About $41,000 went to charitable donations.


Gov. Brad Boy, cannot by law cannot seek a third term, has some options for spending surplus funds.

Those include: giving them to the state, returning them to donors, giving to charity, running for state office, or transferring $5,000 a year to a state or local political party.


He can NOT use them to run for federal office or donate them to other candidates.

X-House Speaker Lance Cargill, who stepped down last week, has raised nearly $250,000 in his re-election bid.

X-House Speaker Cargill, R-Harrah, raised $40,900 during the most recent reporting period from Oct. 1 through Dec. 31.

X-House Speaker Cargill, elected to the House in 2000, has spent $146,843, including $32,370 in the last three months of 2007, reports show.

X-House Speaker Cargill has $128,827 avail-able in campaign funds, reports show. He spent $498,936 on his 2006 campaign.

Donors to Cargill's campaign during the most recent reporting period include lobbyist Bobby Stem, who gave $4,000; Enid businessman John Groendyke, $1,000; former Oklahoma City Mayor Kirk Humphreys, $1,000; Rep. Ron Johnson, R-Kingfisher, $1,000; and legislative consultant Jami Longacre, $1,000.

And giving $1,000 was Bill Case, a lobbyist and former state representative who provided transportation for Cargill and several other Republican state representatives to a fundraiser for GOP presidential candidate Mike Huckabee. It was in the Dallas home of Gene Phillips, who allegedly bribed Oklahoma's ex-insurance commissioner, Carroll Fisher.

Friday, January 25, 2008

Reynolds Praises Ethics Commission Reforms

State Rep. Mike Reynolds praised the Oklahoma Ethics Commission for adopting several major reforms designed to increase public scrutiny of campaign financing.

"By banning PAC-to-PAC transfers, the Ethics Commission has increased the transparency of our campaign financing system," said Reynolds, R-Oklahoma City. "The public has a right to know the identities of the people who bankroll political candidates. But for too long, the rich and powerful have been able to funnel large amounts of cash to their hand-picked candidates without public disclosure thanks to the PAC loophole. The Ethics Commission's decision to ban that practice is a victory for open government and accountability."

In the past, political action committees (or PACS) could contribute money to other PACs without identifying the original sources of the donations. In theory, campaign contributors cannot direct how a PAC will use their contribution, but critics believe that restriction was often violated.

Reynolds also praised the Ethics Commission's decision to limit the amount lobbyists can spend on gifts for legislators to no more than $100 per year. The previous cap was $300 per year.

"Legislators need to avoid even the appearance of
impropriety, but when lobbyists buy expensive
meals or gifts to politicians, it looks too much like
a bribe to working Oklahomans," Reynolds said.
"I'm pleased the commission reduced the amount
lawmakers can legally receive and I hope they
impose greater restrictions in the future."

Thursday, January 24, 2008

Stronger ethics rules on panel's agenda

Stronger ethics rules on panel's agenda

OKLAHOMA CITY -- Stronger ethics rules, including one crafted to stop political action committees from funneling multiple contributions to a candidate in a hot race, will be considered Friday by the Oklahoma Ethics Commission.

Rep. Mike Reynolds, who spends time scrutinizing campaign reports, has proposed the PAC-to-PAC prohibition, which was strongly opposed by some House Republican leaders last spring.

Just before the Legislature adjourned in May, the Ethics Commission reversed itself and dropped the PAC-to-PAC prohibition. Rep. Trebor Worthen, R-Oklahoma City, who leads the House Republican PAC, opposed the rule, saying it would be unconstitutional.

Ethics Commission member John Raley of Ponca City, an attorney, said he has not been able to discover any validity to that claim, adding, "This rule is very necessary."

Reynolds, R-Oklahoma City, said records indicate that candidates with close races were receiving $5,000 contributions from multiple PACs that were working together to contribute to a candidate.

Individuals and PACs are each limited to $5,000 contributions to an individual candidate.

James W. Loy of Chickasha, chairman of the Ethics Commission, is sponsoring the rule.

By law, a donor, including individ uals and PACs, cannot make a campaign contribution to a PAC with the stipulation that it must go to a particular candidate. This prohibition includes "recommending" that a cer- tain candidate should get the donation, said Marilyn Hughes, executive director of the Oklahoma Ethics Commission. But Reynolds suspects that this is happening.

Regarding a proposed ban on giving lawmakers free football tickets, Raley said, "It is difficult for me to see how (receiving football tickets) can enhance good government."

"This is a way of purchasing access" to lawmakers, which is something the public does not have, he added.

OU reported this week that it had provided $300 each to 139 lawmakers for football tickets with the legislators picking up the rest of the cost, or about $35 per ticket. OSU gave 80 lawmakers tickets worth $288 each.

Rules passed by the Ethics Commission become law at the end of the legislative session, which adjourns in late May, unless the lawmakers vote to reject the rules. However, the governor can veto the lawmakers' actions.

The Ethics Commission meets at 10 a.m. Friday in Room 511A at the Capitol.

Meanwhile, two lawmakers have filed bills calling for strong ethics laws, including one that would prohibit lawmakers from accepting contributions when they are writing laws during regular session. Texas and some other states have adopted such a prohibition.




Mick Hinton (405) 528-2465
mick.hinton@tulsaworld.com


UNDER CONSIDERATION

Rules being considered by the state Ethics Commission:

A prohibition on transferring money collected while holding one state office to a race for another office. This proposal resulted after former House Speaker Todd Hiett raised $650,000 in that position and transferred it to his unsuccessful campaign for lieutenant governor.

A ban on lawmakers accepting free football tickets, which would end the tradition of legislators’ receiving tickets for the University of Oklahoma Sooners’ and Oklahoma State University Cowboys’ games.

A $200 limit on gifts that lobbyists can give to lawmakers annually, a reduction from $300.

A limit on how much a lobbyist can spend on a meal provided to a lawmaker, amounting to $15 for lunch and $25 for dinner. This rule is being proposed after lobbyists filed reports showing that several lawmakers were receiving free dinners costing more than $100. Rep. Dennis Adkins, R-Tulsa, who leads the powerful Energy and Technology Committee, led the list of lawmakers receiving free meals and other gifts during the last session.

A requirement that lawmakers would have to list the names of consultants and others who receive payment from the legislator’s campaign account. Lawmakers now list only broad categories of expenses, such as consultants and labor.