Showing posts with label US Supreme Court. Show all posts
Showing posts with label US Supreme Court. Show all posts

Monday, April 28, 2008

US Supreme Court upholds photo ID law for voters in Indiana











The Supreme Court ruled Monday that states can require voters to produce photo identification without violating their constitutional rights, validating Republican-inspired voter ID laws.


In a splintered 6-3 ruling, the court upheld Indiana's strict photo ID requirement, which Democrats and civil rights groups said would deter poor, older and minority voters from casting ballots. Its backers said it was needed to prevent fraud.

It was the most important voting rights case since the Bush v. Gore dispute that sealed the 2000 election for George W. Bush. But the voter ID ruling lacked the conservative-liberal split that marked the 2000 case.

The law "is amply justified by the valid interest in protecting 'the integrity and reliability of the electoral process,'" Justice John Paul Stevens said in an opinion that was joined by Chief Justice John Roberts and Anthony Kennedy. Stevens was a dissenter in Bush v. Gore in 2000.

Justices Samuel Alito, Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas also agreed with the outcome, but wrote separately.

Justices Stephen Breyer, Ruth Bader Ginsburg and David Souter dissented, just as they did in 2000.

More than 20 states require some form of identification at the polls. Courts have upheld voter ID laws in Arizona, Georgia and Michigan, but struck down Missouri's. Monday's decision comes a week before Indiana's presidential primary.

The decision also could spur efforts to pass similar laws in other states.

Ken Falk, legal director of the American Civil Liberties Union of Indiana, said he hadn't reviewed the decision, but he was "extremely disappointed" by it. Falk has said voter ID laws inhibit voting, and a person's right to vote "is the most important right." The ACLU brought the case on behalf of Indiana voters.

The case concerned a state law, passed in 2005, that was backed by Republicans as a way to deter voter fraud. Democrats and civil rights groups opposed the law as unconstitutional and called it a thinly veiled effort to discourage elderly, poor and minority voters — those most likely to lack proper ID and who tend to vote for Democrats.

There is little history in Indiana of either in-person voter fraud — of the sort the law was designed to thwart — or voters being inconvenienced by the law's requirements. For the overwhelming majority of voters, an Indiana driver license serves as the identification.

"We cannot conclude that the statute imposes 'excessively burdensome requirements' on any class of voters," Stevens said.

Stevens' opinion suggests that the outcome could be different in a state where voters could provide evidence that their rights had been impaired.

But in dissent, Souter said Indiana's voter ID law "threatens to impose nontrivial burdens on the voting rights of tens of thousands of the state's citizens."

Scalia, favoring a broader ruling in defense of voter ID laws, said, "The universally applicable requirements of Indiana's voter-identification law are eminently reasonable. The burden of acquiring, possessing and showing a free photo identification is simply not severe, because it does not 'even represent a significant increase over the usual burdens of voting.'"

Stevens said the partisan divide in Indiana, as well as elsewhere, was noteworthy. But he said that preventing fraud and inspiring voter confidence were legitimate goals of the law, regardless of who backed or opposed it.

Indiana provides IDs free of charge to the poor and allows voters who lack photo ID to cast a provisional ballot and then show up within 10 days at their county courthouse to produce identification or otherwise attest to their identity.

Stevens said these provisions also help reduce the burden on people who lack driver licenses.


Excerpts from Monday's 6-3 Supreme Court decision
upholding Indiana's law requiring voters to present a
picture ID before they vote:

Justice John Paul Stevens, writing to uphold the law:
"Indiana's own experience with fraudulent voting in the 2003 Democratic primary for East Chicago mayor — though perpetrated using absentee ballots and not in-person fraud — demonstrate that not only is the risk of voter fraud real but that it could affect the outcome of a close election."


"The record says virtually nothing about the difficulties faced by either indigent voters or voters with religious objections to being photographed. ... In sum, on the basis of the record that has been made in this litigation, we cannot conclude that the statute imposes 'excessively burdensome requirements' on any class of voters."

"Finally we note that petitioners have not demonstrated that the proper remedy — even assuming an unjustified burden on some voters — would be to invalidate the entire statute."

"In their briefs, petitioners stress the fact that all of the Republicans in the General Assembly voted in favor" of the law "and the Democrats were unanimous in opposing it. ... It is fair to infer that partisan considerations may have played a significant role in the decision to enact" the law and "if such considerations had provided the only justification for a photo identification requirement, we may assume" that the law "would suffer the same fate as the poll tax. But if a nondiscriminatory law is supported by valid neutral justifications, those justifications should not be disregarded simply because partisan interests may have provided one motivation for the votes of individual legislators.

Justice Antonin Scalia, concurring:
"The lead opinion assumes petitioners' premise that the voter-identification law 'may have imposed a special burden on' some voters, but holds that petitioners have not assembled evidence to show that the special burden is severe enough to warrant strict scrutiny. That is true enough, but for the sake of clarity and finality as well as adherence to precedent, I prefer to decide these cases on the grounds that petitioners' premise is irrelevant and that the burden at issue is minimal and justified."


"This calls for application of a deferential 'important regulatory interests' standard for nonsecure, nondiscriminatory restrictions, reserving strict scrutiny for laws that severely restrict the right to vote."

Tuesday, March 25, 2008

Justices Rebuff Bush and World Court




Justices Rebuff Bush and
World Court

Powers Limited in Texas Death Case


The Supreme Court yesterday issued a broad ruling limiting presidential power and the reach of international treaties, saying neither President Bush nor the World Court has the authority to order a Texas court to reopen a death penalty case involving a foreign national.

The justices held 6 to 3 that judgments of the International Court of Justice, as the court is formally known, are not binding on U.S. courts and that Bush's 2005 executive order that courts in Texas comply anyway does not change that.

The decision, written by Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr., was a rebuke to the government in a case that involved the powers of all three branches of government, the intricacies of treaties and the international debate over the death penalty.

It placed the president on the side of Ernesto Medell¿n, a brutal murderer, and the rulings of the World Court, and against the authority of his home state's courts.

Texas's high court had rejected the World Court's judgment that it "review and reconsider" Medell¿n's conviction because he is a Mexican national and was not advised after his arrest that he could meet with a consular from his country, as the Vienna Convention requires.

Even though the administration disagreed with the World Court' s decision -- and has withdrawn from the international pact that gave it force -- Bush nonetheless issued a memorandum ordering the Texas courts to rehear Medell¿n's case.

But Roberts wrote that neither the Optional Protocol of the Vienna Convention nor the operative part of the United Nations Charter creates binding law in the absence of implementing legislation from Congress.
And he wrote that the government had not made the case that Bush had the power to issue a directive that "reaches deep into the heart of the state's police powers and compels state courts to reopen final criminal judgments and set aide neutrally applicable state laws."

Joining Roberts were the justices who are most consistently conservative: Antonin Scalia, Anthony M. Kennedy, Clarence Thomas and Samuel A. Alito Jr.

Justice John Paul Stevens concurred, but for different reasons than Roberts gave. Stevens agreed that Texas could not be forced to reconsider the case but urged it to do so nonetheless, especially because its failure to advise Medell¿n of his rights "ensnared the United States in the current controversy."

Justice Stephen G. Breyer wrote in dissent that the court had misread the supremacy clause of the Constitution, which says properly ratified treaties "shall be the supreme law of the land" and that the treaties at issue did not need to be implemented by congressional legislation. "As a result, the nation may well break its word even though the president seeks to live up to that word and Congress has done nothing to suggest the contrary," Breyer wrote. He was joined by Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg and David H. Souter.

Roberts said to accept Medell¿n's argument would make World Court decisions not only binding domestic law but also "unassailable."

Bush's intentions -- to ensure reciprocal observance of the Vienna Convention with foreign governments, protect international relations and show a commitment to international law -- are "plainly compelling," Roberts wrote. "Such considerations, however, do not allow us to set aside first principles."

Frederick L. Kirgis, a professor of international law at Washington and Lee University, said he was surprised that the court was not more deferential to the president.

"It is a matter of diplomacy, after all, and the president is the chief diplomat, and he has acted," Kirgis said, adding that the reaction of other governments, especially Mexico's, is "certain to be negative."

The Mexican Foreign Affairs Ministry said it regretted the court's decision and its lawyers are reviewing the implications for "other Mexican nationals facing death sentences, in order to determine immediate legal actions to preserve their rights."

The case involved Medell¿n and 50 other Mexican nationals who have been convicted in U.S. courts.

Medell¿n, 33, has lived in the United States since he was 3; he speaks and writes English but is still a Mexican national. He was part of a gang that attacked Jennifer Ertman, 14, and Elizabeth Pe¿a, 16, as they walked home from a friend's house. They were raped and murdered, one strangled with her shoestring.

Medell¿n signed a waiver of his Miranda right to remain silent and confessed within hours of his arrest. But he was not told of his right to talk to the consulate of his country. Medell¿n did not raise that right during his trial but did in one of his death penalty appeals.

The administration first argued against Mexico, and then in 2005 Bush issued his memorandum to the attorney general saying that the United States will "discharge its international obligations . . . by having state courts give effect to the decision" of the World Court.

White House press secretary Dana Perino said Bush was disappointed with the decision and is reviewing it to see how it might influence international relations.

Friday, January 18, 2008

US Supreme Court Justices visit OU law next week

The University of Oklahoma College of Law will make history next week when two U.S. Supreme Court justices participate in activities surrounding the investiture ceremony of Robert H. Henry to the position of chief judge of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

OU law students will view the proceedings as the Court sits for oral arguments at the OU Law Center on Wednesday, Thursday and Friday. OU President David Boren will preside Thursday evening over a fireside chat with Stephen Breyer, associate justice of the U.S. Supreme Court since 1994, and Sandra Day O'Connor, associate justice of the U.S. Supreme Court from 1981 to 2006. Justice Breyer also will address OU law students and faculty Thursday afternoon as keynote speaker for the Henry Family Lecture in Jurisprudence.

Henry, an OU alumnus who served as state representative from 1975 to 1986 and as state attorney general from 1987 to 1991, will be formally invested as chief judge of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit in ceremonies Friday. The investiture ceremony, which is open to OU students, faculty and staff, will begin 1:30 p.m. in the Donald W. Reynolds Performing Arts Center, 560 Parrington Oval. ?

"The university is proud to host this event, which honors one of our law graduates, Robert Henry, and his exceptional record as a member of the U.S. Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals," OU President David Boren said.

Justices Breyer and O'Connor will offer remarks during the investiture ceremony. Other participants, in addition to Boren and the Supreme Court justices, will be Gov. Brad Henry; Andrew M. Coats, university vice president and dean of the OU College of Law; soprano Leona Mitchell, who will sing the national anthem; and Pulitzer Prize-winner N. Scott Momaday, who will give a poetry reading. Remarks also will be offered by the outgoing chief judge of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, Deanell Reece Tacha, and David M. Ebel, who has served on the Tenth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals since 1988. Adding to the pomp and circumstance of the ceremony will be the Kiowa Black Leggings Society and the Pipes and Drums of the Highlanders, both well-known for their appearances at OU's commencement ceremonies.

Henry joined the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals, the Denver-based court that serves Oklahoma, Kansas, New Mexico, Colorado, Wyoming and Utah, in 1994. As chief judge, Henry will oversee administration of the court, play a key role in misconduct complaints against federal judges in the six states and become a member of the Judicial Conference of the United States, the policy-making body for the federal court system.

Henry was born in 1953 in Shawnee. He earned his bachelor of arts degree with high honors and his juris doctorate in 1974 and 1976, respectively, from OU. At age 23, a month before his graduation from law school, he defeated five other candidates in an election for a seat in the state House of Representatives. Henry became vice chairman of the House Judiciary Committee by his second term. He later became chairman of both the Judiciary and Education committees and chairman of the appropriations subcommittee, where he was in a position to oversee all legislation affecting the judicial system in Oklahoma, as well as the Majority Caucus. During his time in the House, he also worked as a part-time associate in a Shawnee law firm.

Henry left the Legislature in 1986, when he was elected the state's attorney general; he was re-elected in 1990 without opposition. As the state's chief legal official, he not only supervised thousands of cases but also helped create a new state ethics commission and revamped the state's grand jury system. As AG, he also fought consumer fraud.

Henry has served as dean and professor of law in the Oklahoma City University School of Law from 1991 to 1994 and as visiting faculty at Oklahoma Baptist University and the University of Tulsa.

He has been awarded numerous human rights, humanitarian and environmental awards in Oklahoma. In 2004, he was awarded the OU College of Arts and Sciences' Distinguished Alumni Award, and in 2005, Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist appointed Henry as chair of the Judicial Conference Committee on International Judicial Relations.

A limited number of seats are available to OU students, faculty and staff for the Fireside Chat and Dinner. OU students, faculty and staff interested in attending the fireside chat and dinner Thursday can make reservations by calling the Action Line at 325-1212. No reservations are required for OU students, faculty and staff attending the investiture ceremony at the Donald W. Reynolds Performing Arts Center. Doors will open at 1 p.m. with overflow seating available in the Rupel Jones Theatre. For accommodations on the basis of disability for either event, call the Office of Special Events at 325-3784.